BEFORE THE INTERVIEW:
11
General Principles of Negotiating Salary
PRINCIPLE 1: POSTPONE
THE NEGOTIATION
Never begin salary
negotiation before receiving a firm job offer. If your interviewer mentions
the salary issue at the beginning of the interview, you can respond with
something like:"Thank you so much for mentioning this issue. Before we discuss
this, may I ask you ... ?"
This technique will move
the conversation away from the salary issue. Ask questions regarding the
responsibilities, the tasks, the mission of the job. If the interviewer has
you "on the ropes" and will not be dissuaded from discussing the salary
issue, do not lose your chance at a good job by refusing to discuss this
issue. Instead, quote a very broad salary range or use one of the following
four strategies to postpone salary negotiation.
1. Bounce back the
question to the interviewer.
"I am sure that you have
budgeted an amount for this job. What sort of range does the salary curve or
your budget show?"
"I have an idea of what
the market offers for this type of job. Could we please begin by discussing
what your company is prepared to offer?"
“A company like yours
surely has an idea of the salary range to be offered. What do your salary
curves suggest?"
2. Stall Elegantly
"I am sure we will come
to a fair agreement on salary once we have established I am the right person
for the job."
"Salary isn't the issue
here. I know that I have to produce more than I cost. First, let's figure out
how much I will produce for you."
"Salary is the third item
on my working conditions list. First, let's establish that we can work
together. Second, let me show you how, through my job/work I will contribute
positively to your organization. Then, as a third point, we can discuss the
salary issue."
3. Use Your Sense of
Humor
Your job as interviewer
is to make me talk about salary! My job as interviewee is to remain silent on
this issue! Isn't it?"
"I never like to talk
about salary for a job I am not sure is right for me. Could we first see if I
am the right candidate for the job?"
"What I expect from a job
is far greater than what I expect from a salary!"
4. Disarm Your
Interviewer
"Discussing the money
issue at this stage of the interview is a little bit premature, don't you
think?"
"I hope you won't mind if
I ask to postpone this discussion for now."
"As a principle, I don't
like to discuss salary prior to being offered a job. I'm sure you can
understand that."
"I'm sure the salary
offered for this job will be fair, equitable, and satisfactory."
PRINCIPLE 2: AVOID
MENTIONING YOUR LAST SALARY
There are at least five
reasons why an interview( wants to know your last salary or your salary
expectations as soon as possible (preferably even before the interview).This
knowledge allows him to:
- gauge where you fit in
the salary range;
- screen you out quickly
if the number of candidates is large, as salary is an ideal and obvious way to
compare candidates and screen them out;
- save money if your
actual or last salary is below the one budgeted for the job;
- know the market better;
- evaluate your level of
entry into his company (competency ratio).
When reacting to a
question regarding your actual (or last) salary, it is essential not to answer
at all. One of these four tactics will help you.
1. Range. When your
interviewer asks you what your current/last salary is/was, give only a broad
range:
Q: How much do you make
in your present job?
A: In my present job my
salary is exactly in the range I'm shooting for now: between
and
Tactic 2: Gentlemen's
Agreement. If you come from a company or work for an organization where there
is a gentlemen's agreement about nondisclosure of salaries, seize this
opportunity not to answer.
Q: How much do you make
in your present job? A: At XYZ company, where I work now, there
is a gentleman's
agreement about nondisclosure of salary. I must stick to the moral commitment
I made to-them not to discuss my salary with anyone.
Tactic 3: Later Stage
Disclosure. This tactic consists of proposing to give the information to your
interviewer at a later stage. This means you will disclose the information but
only after you have negotiated a salary with him. This method is common in
highly competitive fields, such as computer or telephone systems sales. When
your interviewer asks you to tell him your current/previous salary, do it as
described below.
Q: How much do you make
in your present job? A: Would you like to see a copy of my last pay slip or
should I just tell you my salary?
Q: No, just tell me.
A: Well, before I tell
you I would like to negotiate my future salary with you. When we have an
agreement, I will
disclose my former salary.
Your interviewer may then
smile and tell you that you are a "tough negotiator." Simply thank him and
say, "The toughness and style I bring to the negotiation table, I will bring
to work for you full time in my new job!"
Tactic 4: Anticipated
Salary. If you are presently in a job, this technique consists of telling the
salary you will be making after your next promotion.
Q: How much do you make
in your present job?
A: After my next
promotion, which occurs in four months, my salary will be raised to
PRINCIPLE 3: MAKE THEM
TALK FIRST
In the good old Western
movies, in the final duel scene, there was always a good guy and a bad guy. In
the traditional movie, the bad guy was the first to move but the good guy
always drew faster and shot the bad guy dead! The same thing happens in salary
negotiation: The first one who makes a move, gets shot down! It is always best
to talk last. Wait for the interviewer to expose himself. Effectively
postponing the negotiation and making the interviewer talk first has several
advantages. Most importantly you:
- get a better salary
offer than you originally planned;
- refrain from "shooting
yourself in the foot" by asking for too low a figure, or from ending the
negotiation by asking for too high a figure;
-"up the ante" more
easily when salary is finally discussed later;
- take the necessary time
to obtain specific information about the level of the job and its
corresponding responsibilities;
- can gauge how the
interviewer is evaluating you before you have to negotiate with him;
- discover the starting
point of the negotiation process.
Sometimes an interviewer
will try to open negotiations by coming right out and asking how much money
you want to make. It is important not to take the bait and simply state a
figure or a range. To keep the advantage, tactfully turn the question back on
to your interviewer:
Q: How much do you want
to earn?
A: Oh, thank you for
raising this issue. Before answering you, I'd like to ask a question. Q:
Please do.
A: Do you have salary
curves or indexes in your organization? Q: Yes, of course we do.
A: Could you tell me,
then, what sort of salary range you have in mind for this job, based on those
curves? This will make things easier and save us time.
PRINCIPLE 4: KEEP YOUR
OPTIONS OPEN
Sometimes the interviewer
will mention salary early in the interview as if it were predetermined and
nonnegotiable. He may say something like: "We have projected a salary
of for this job," or "The final figure we have is
." Although, in accordance with Principle 2, you will probably want to delay
discussions of salary at this point, Principle 2 applies only when the
interviewer is prematurely wanting you to discuss salary. In this case, he may
be simply trying to slip a figure by you without further discussion. If you do
not reply in some way, your silence could be taken as an acceptance of the
stated salary. If a figure is given, it is important not to simply nod in
understanding or otherwise let the remark go by. This may foreclose your
ability to negotiate later. Instead, you must acknowledge that the subject of
salary has come up without either agreeing or disagreeing and then either 1)
employ strategies to postpone further discussion, or 2) follow the strategy
discussed below.
Sometimes, after stating
a figure, the interviewer will ask, "Would that fit you?," "Do you agree?,"
or, "Is that the sort of range you are interested in?" Never simply say that
you agree or disagree. Instead, simply state, "This figure fits perfectly into
my range." This rather open-ended reply can accomplish several things:
- keep the discussion
from getting stalled or stuck, or prematurely focused on salary;
- keep you from being
tied solely to the amount the interviewer proposes;
- keep you from having to
accept his offer;
- allow you to continue
the interview with all your salary options open.
Consider the following
dialog to see how the interview might progress in this situation:
Q: We have budgeted
for this job.
A: This figure fits
perfectly into my range.
Then you can proceed,
using facts and figures to show him that you are the right person for the job,
listing achievements that match his needs. When you receive the job offer,you
are in a position to continue:
A: Can we now negotiate
my salary with your organization?
Q: We have already done
it!
A: Yes, you already told
me what sort of budget you have for this job and I told you that this
figure fits exactly in my
range. Now that I know what the job entails, I can better narrow down
my range from
to .
Now you can simply state
your range and begin the negotiation. Make sure the lower figure of your range
is close to the figure stated by the interviewer.
PRINCIPLE 5: UP THE ANTE
If you have successfully
postponed negotiation to the proper time, and if you have succeeded in making
the interviewer mention the first figure, it is now your job to "up the ante."
One very effective method is to use "The Echo."
"The Echo" is just what
it sounds like: simply repeat the figure stated by the interviewer and then
remain silent. Whatever amount is stated, do not show a reaction. Your face
should remain calm and unchanged. The full technique looks like this:
1.Your interviewer has
spoken first and mentioned a salary of . Repeat this figure
exactly with only the slightest suggestion of a surprise or question.
2. Look the interviewer
in the eyes, or if this embarrasses you, look at his eyebrows or the right or
left side of his face.
3. Do not be overt. Do
not show satisfaction or deception, only the faintest hint of a surprise.
4.The very fact that you
repeat the amount and then remain silent, showing no other reaction, may cause
the interviewer to be perplexed. As a result, he may increase his offer.
You will want to
practice this technique because it can feel awkward. When a figure is
mentioned, a reaction is expected, and your impulse will be to give one -
either positive or negative. If you have rehearsed well, however, you can hold
your emotions in check, and maintain a calm, cool silence after you have
simply repeated the figure. It may feel awkward, but that's exactly why it's
effective. Your interviewer will want to break the awkward silence-usually by
suggesting a higher figure!
Here's an example of a
dialog using the "Echo" technique:
A: May I ask what sort of
salary you have budgeted for this job?
Q: We have budgeted
around 100.
A: 100?...
Remain silent and wait
for the interviewer to break the pause.
Q: Yes, 100... but this
is not our final offer! A: This is not your final offer?...
One last note: if the
interviewer mentions a range instead of a flat figure, repeat the higher
figure when using the Echo technique. It can be just as effective!
PRINCIPLE 6: NARROW THE
GAP
If the salary you desire
is higher than the one being offered, try to fill that gap and that gap only.
Furthermore, try to make the gap appear as small as possible. If you are
speaking in terms of an annual salary, for example, divide the salary gap by
12 to make it a monthly figure, which appears smaller.
For instance, if you
want an annual salary of 112 and you are offered 100, focus on the gap of 12
(112-100 = 12). Divide this yearly gap of 12 by 12 months, to get a monthly
gap of one. This is then the place to begin your negotiation: "Actually, we
are very close to each other - our gap is only 1 per month. Can we see what we
can do about this?"
PRINCIPLE 7: NEGOTIATE
FUTURE SALARY INCREASES
There are two types of
increases for salaries: an automatic one to reflect a cost of living increase,
and a discretionary one to reflect the merit of your performance or
efficiency. Ask the interviewer one of the three following questions:
1."As I hope to make my
career with your organization, could you please let me know your policy for
salary increases?"
2."We have discussed the
base salary. I am sure, in an organization like yours, there is a yearly
adjustment to reflect a cost of living increase as well as a merit increase.
Could you please elaborate on this?"
3."I am very interested
in the future I could have with your organization and would like you to
elaborate on two points. First, when will the first raise be given? Second,
will this raise reflect only a cost of living increase, or will it also
include a merit adjustment?"
After you have asked
this type of question, you must try to shorten the period until your first
salary increase. This period should be as short as possible. There are three
ways to shorten this timeframe, running from an "elegant understatement" to an
ultimatum. Consider how the overall interview and negotiation has gone so far,
and use your instinct to decide which tactic is best:
1."Could we consider
making the timeframe for a salary increase shorter than your usual policy?"
2."The period between now
and the first increase is long. By how many months could you shorten this?"
3."I like your salary
offer. However, I can only accept it if you are willing to give me a raise
within months."
PRINCIPLE 8: AVOID
BLUFFING
A large majority of
people believe it is hard to negotiate without some bluffing taking place.
However, experience shows that the most successful negotiations are done
without bluffing and are organized around very smart strategies of information
retention.
You will be more
efficient if you stick to the truth for several reasons:
- the very fact that you
use only true information makes you feel more comfortable and secure, which
makes the interview easier for you;
- when checking is done
after the interview, your integrity and good faith are proven and you benefit
from this;
- bluffing, lies, or
exaggeration can hamper the otherwise good negotiation tactics at your
disposal and quite possibly close the door on an interesting job.
PRINCIPLE 9: STAND YOUR
GROUND
If you are firm and
persistent, you may fear your interviewer will feel you are somewhat
inflexible, but it is more likely he will respect your tenacity and self- -
confidence, which will only increase his esteem for you. If, however, you feel
embarrassed and wish to lighten the mood (humor has never hampered a good
negotiation), you can try one of the four following strategies.
1. Agree with Gentle
Humor
Q: You certainly are
tough when it comes
to negotiating! A: Why,
thank you!
2.Turn Negatives to
Positives
Q: You seem so sure of
yourself. It appears that nothing will make you budge.
A: Yes, this is a
compliment given to me by many of my past employers.
3. Common Sense
Q: You appear to be a
person who is always watching out for himself.
A: Do you think so?
Q: Yes, you seem to be
very interested in the money aspect of this job.
A: The job to be filled
requires excellent negotiation skills. I am demonstrating that
I have those skills.
Later, when I work for you, I will fight and negotiate just as firmly on your
behalf.
4.One-Upmanship
Q: As a negotiator, you
are not what I would call easy.
A: Oh, thank you! I am
convinced that you are testing me right now. Shall we try arm wrestling too?
PRINCIPLE 10: NO
TELEPHONE NEGOTIATION-EVER!
Turn down any proposal
to negotiate salary over the telephone. Use the telephone only to confirm that
you accept a firm job offer. All other details must be negotiated in person.
Negotiating by phone has two main disadvantages:
- You cannot see your
interviewer and therefore you cannot measure his interest (or indifference) to
what you are saying.
- Your negotiation
position is weaker and you are more vulnerable. If there is any type of
mismatch, the split will be one that you cannot address again.
If, as sometimes
happens, you feel that your interviewer is trying to renegotiate an already
agreed-upon salary over the phone, adopt one of the two following attitudes:
- If you do not want to
renegotiate, remain firm and say you do not wish to reconsider the previous
offer.
- If you are willing to
reopen the negotiation, say that-as a principle-you never negotiate money
issues over the phone and arrange for an immediate appointment.
PRINCIPLE 11: GET IT IN
WRITING
Accepting a firm job
offer together with a salary proposal can be done either verbally or in
writing. However, a confirmation in writing is a must in the following four
cases:
- if you have some sort
of negative intuition or feeling about your interviewer and have doubts about
the value of his word;
- if the promises made to
you seem too numerous or generous to be given without something more being
demanded of you some time down the road;
- if the salary formula
is complex (due to adjustments, commissions, etc.), or if you think the salary
has not been stated clearly or not negotiated thoroughly enough;
- if the risk to you is
great. For instance, if you must resign from a present job to take a new job
the risk is too large to accept without having a firm written proposal in your
hand, signed by the person for whom you will actually be working.
If the interviewer is
reluctant to commit in writing, suggest that you write the letter for him to
sign, saying, "How do you want to proceed? Do you plan to confirm this offer
in writing yourself or would you prefer that I do it?" If the new employer
agrees that you should write the letter, be sure to stress the interest you
have for the job and exactly what has been agreed upon by the two of you. Send
your new employer two copies, signed by you. Ask him to sign one and return it
to you in an enclosed stamped self-addressed envelope.